Gloria Family Law logo

Debt and Divorce: When One Spouse Pays Alone

PublishedLast reviewed:14 min read
Separating couple going over tax debt and loan paperwork in an Australian family law property settlement
Section 79 of the Family Law Act 1975 demands a fair outcome. Courts often split debts between separating spouses, but a debt born of one spouse's recklessness or deception can be left squarely with that spouse.

Introduction

Q1: My husband built up a tax debt before separation. Am I on the hook for it too?

A: Not automatically. A tax debt does not become joint just because it grew during the marriage. In a 2025 appeal, the husband could have cleared a $41,398 tax bill but never did, and instead handed $140,000 to his sister. The court left every dollar of it with him. Reference: Shamon [2025] FedCFamC1A 150

Q2: My ex's debt came from their own fraud. Will I be made to share it?

A: Almost certainly not. Courts will not charge you for a debt your ex created through their own dishonesty. In one case, a wife claimed a benefit she was not entitled to and ran up a Centrelink debt of about $106,000; the judge gave the husband no share of it at all. Reference: Rose [2012] FamCA 236

Q3: My ex claims a big debt to their parents. Does my share shrink because of it?

A: Only if the loan is genuine and legally enforceable. In a 2025 case, a mother asserted she owed her father $437,885. The court accepted only $150,000 backed by formal loan agreements and spent on things other than legal fees. The loan for her legal fees, and every undocumented advance, was left out. Reference: Stubbs (No 3) [2025] FedCFamC1F 534

How does Australian law treat debt in a divorce?

In a property settlement, the court's usual first step is to list everything the couple owns, subtract everything they owe, and divide the remainder — the property pool. That sequence is a working convention, not a legal requirement. Under section 79 of the Family Law Act 1975, the court may only make property orders that are just and equitable. Which means that, for any given debt, one question decides it: would it be fair for both of you to carry it?

Across more than four decades of decisions, the courts have marked out the situations in which a debt tends to stay with the spouse who created it:

  1. Recklessness or waste. In Kowaliw & Kowaliw (1981) FLC 91-092, Baker J held that losses incurred during a marriage should be shared, though not necessarily equally. The exception is where one spouse deliberately diminished the value of the assets, or handled them recklessly, negligently or wantonly. Vinge [2013] FCCA 2196 applied that test to a husband's unpaid tax.
  2. Debts incurred in disregard of the other spouse's rights. In Biltoft & Biltoft [1995] FamCA 45, the Full Court (the Family Court's appeal bench) held that a debt may be left out of account where a spouse ran it up in deliberate or reckless disregard of the other spouse's entitlement. The passage appears in Commissioner of Taxation & Worsnop [2009] FamCAFC 4 at [54].
  3. Debts that will likely never be collected. Money lent by parents to an adult child is the classic case. Where nobody expects the lender to pursue repayment, the court can exclude the loan from its calculations. Liakos & Zervos [2011] FamCA 547 did exactly that with a $1.39 million debt to the husband's father.
  4. Debts with no legal existence. A promise made without any intention to create a legally enforceable debt counts for nothing. Stubbs (No 3) [2025] FedCFamC1F 534 excluded family advances that lacked loan agreements.

The Full Court reaffirmed all of this in 2025. It refused to accept that a tax debt accruing before separation must automatically count as joint, since such a rule would invite one spouse to pile on liabilities after separation:

"That is, merely because a taxation debt accrued prior to separation does not mandate it being brought to account as a joint matrimonial liability (Chorn & Hopkins [2004] FamCA 633; (2004) FLC 93-204 at [71]). To create such a principle would leave open between separation and trial the opportunity for a party to organise or manipulate finances to maximise liabilities in the hands of one party and not to give justice between the parties"

The same judgment makes a practical point: the spouse who wants a debt brought to account must persuade the court to count it (at [67]). So when your ex says a debt should eat into your share, the burden of proving that sits with them.

Core Point: Nothing in the law automatically makes a debt joint because it arose during the marriage or sits in both names. The court asks whether sharing it is fair, and examines closely how the debt came about and who profited from it.

Why does it matter so much who carries a debt?

In a property settlement, debts come off the pool before anything is divided. Treat a $400,000 debt as joint and the pool is $400,000 smaller before any percentage is applied; leave it with your ex and your share is worked out on the larger, unshrunken pool. That arithmetic is exactly how a single large debt can swallow your entire share. Get it wrong and three things can happen:

  • You foot the bill for your ex's decisions. Tax your ex deliberately left unpaid, or money borrowed after separation, gets carved out of your share.
  • You leave with nothing. When liabilities outrun assets, whoever holds fewer of them usually exits in better shape.
  • The creditor can still come after you. An order between spouses does not extinguish a bank loan taken in your name. In practice, what protects you is usually an order requiring your ex to discharge the debt and indemnify you (stand behind you if the lender pursues you).
Case Analysis: Adair & Milford [2015] FamCAFC 29

The couple had spent roughly 15 years together and had two daughters. By trial, their liabilities exceeded their assets, the largest being the husband's $419,000 tax debt, of which at least $220,000 predated separation. The wife had never known he was not paying his tax, and after separation she was misled into believing the debt was being serviced.

The husband argued the tax debt was joint and should be carried by both of them. The trial judge rejected that. On the evidence, he earned a strong income, maintained the same comfortable standard of living after separation, and abandoned an agreement under which two properties would have been sold to clear debt. The judge found he had the capacity to pay, consciously chose not to, and kept the wife misinformed.

Outcome: The tax debt and roughly $13,000 in credit card debt were left entirely with the husband. The wife took what remained, expected to amount to little once the properties sold, along with her own debts of $176,000 in legal fees and $111,000 owed to her parents. The Full Court dismissed his appeal, holding that the facts constituted the compelling circumstances in which a court may leave one spouse solely responsible for a tax debt.

"There is no principle of general application that merely because a taxation debt accrued prior to separation it must be brought to account as a joint matrimonial liability (Trustee of the Property of G Lemnos, a Bankrupt & Lemnos and Anor (2009) FLC 93-394). In our view, the facts as found amount to what the Full Court in Johnson and Johnson [1999] FamCA 369; (2000) FLC 93-039 described as 'compelling circumstances' which would enable the court to leave one party solely responsible for his or her taxation debt."

Key Point: The husband lost because of his own conduct. He could pay, declined to, and kept his wife in the dark. Every one of those findings came out of his own financial statements and spending records — which is why evidence about the other spouse's income and lifestyle carries such weight.

Will your ex be left to carry their own tax debt?

Unpaid tax generates more debt disputes in property settlements than anything else. The outcome turns on why the tax went unpaid and where the money ended up.

Common Misconception: Tax on income earned during the marriage is automatically a joint debt.

Legal Truth: Tax debts are frequently shared, since the household typically lived on the income that was never taxed. But where a spouse lets their tax slide through negligence or reckless indifference, the court can load most or all of the debt onto that spouse.

Case Analysis: Vinge [2013] FCCA 2196

The couple began living together in 1987, married in 1988 and separated in 2013. The husband ran his own business and had already been in financial strife between 2001 and 2003, when the wife agreed to an overdraft to see him through. Then, across the 2004 to 2012 financial years, he lodged not a single personal tax return and paid no income tax. By trial he owed the tax office $164,257 in unpaid tax plus $11,869 in penalties and interest.

The husband said post-traumatic stress disorder explained his failure, and that he was not deliberately dodging tax. The judge did not accept that the condition left him unable to manage his affairs: during those same years he coached a sports team and served as club president. The judge found he had the money to pay, failed to through negligence or reckless indifference, and had not shown that the unpaid tax went to the family.

Outcome: The husband alone carried the $11,869 in penalties and interest. The unpaid tax itself was divided: 50% was deducted from the pool as a joint debt, and the husband bore the remaining 50% on his own. The judge's reasoning was that the tax, had it been paid when due, would have been absorbed into family spending, so the wife could not be let off entirely.

"Regarding the unpaid tax debt of $164,257, I conclude that the husband's negligence or reckless indifference towards his taxation responsibilities was at such a level that it would indeed be unjust and inequitable to include the outstanding ATO debt as a joint matrimonial liability."

Where the money behind the unpaid tax supported the family, the result flips. Compare these three appeals:

ComparisonAdair & Milford [2015]Pandelis [2018]James & Snipper [2018]
Tax debt size$419,000$98,000, all accruing after separation$2,013,218 by June 2017
Where the money ended upHusband carried on an affluent lifestyle after separationMortgage repayments, money to the wife, private school fees and other family outgoingsSome gambling, but also a comfortable family life and post-separation support for the wife
The other spouse's knowledgeWife misled into believing the tax was being paidTrial judge accepted the husband gave a truthful account of his tax and incomeWife drew substantial benefit from the unpaid tax
ResultDebt left entirely with the husbandLeaving it with him was an error; appeal allowedWife ordered to bear $200,000 of it; appeal dismissed

Key: Read side by side, the three appeals all turn on who pocketed the benefit of the money that should have gone to the tax office. In Pandelis, the husband could not pay his tax because he was funding entirely legitimate family commitments, so the Full Court found no principled basis for excluding the debt. In James & Snipper, the wife enjoyed the lifestyle that unpaid tax financed, so she had to contribute even though she owed the tax office nothing personally. Only in Adair, where the money served the husband alone, did the entire debt stay with him.

If your ex is relying on a tax debt to cut down your share:

  1. Request their tax returns, notices of assessment and tax office account statements for every year the debt spans.
  2. Set their income and spending against what they actually paid the tax office. Holidays, gifts and discretionary purchases made while tax went unpaid make strong evidence.
  3. Find out whether they struck a payment plan with the tax office and later defaulted on it.
  4. Be honest about your own benefit. If untaxed money kept your household running, expect to carry part of the debt.

How do courts treat debts born of fraud or engineered to shrink the pool?

Some debts exist purely because one spouse acted dishonestly. Others surface conveniently soon after separation. Courts are reluctant to make the other spouse carry either kind.

Common Misconception: A debt registered against the family home is automatically deducted first.

Legal Truth: The court examines how and when the debt came into existence. A debt produced by one spouse's fraud, or structured to defeat the other's claim, can be left wholly with its creator.

Case Analysis: Rose [2012] FamCA 236

The couple married in 1998, finally separated in 2008, and had two children who lived with their father after a parenting trial. When the property case was heard, neither side had much. The husband held about $295,000 in property but said he owed his parents $458,413 in legal fees. The wife had no assets of value, $130,000 in unpaid legal fees and a Centrelink debt of roughly $106,000.

The wife accepted the Centrelink debt was the product of her own fraud: she had drawn a benefit she was not entitled to. Appearing without a lawyer, she claimed $200,000 plus half the husband's shares and bank accounts, arguing it was unfair to walk away from a relationship of more than a decade with nothing.

Outcome: The judge concluded there was no net property to divide. Even setting aside part of the husband's debt to his parents, nothing would reach the wife unless her entitlement exceeded $106,000, because the Centrelink debt was hers and hers alone. Each spouse kept their own property, and their own debts.

"The wife advances no argument, nor do I consider it in any event just and equitable, for the husband to share in a debt accrued solely through fraudulent conduct of the wife."

Debt generated after separation can meet the same fate. In Ursino & Baratos [2023] FedCFamC2F 933, an employee of the husband's company deposited $550,000 into the couple's joint account in 2016 on what was called a handshake deal. Within months the husband drew the money out in entries recorded as loans to himself, saying it went into his business, which later collapsed. No paperwork traced its final destination. After the couple separated in 2018, the husband signed a fresh loan agreement granting the lender a second mortgage over the family home. He did so without the wife's knowledge, and after she had lodged a caveat protecting her interest. The court held that the arrangement converted an unsecured business loan into a debt secured over the home:

"I accept the wife's submission that the 2018 arrangement between Mr Baratos and Mr J was intended to diminish the wife's claims in this proceeding."

The $550,000 was not admitted as a liability of the marriage, and no part of it was laid on the wife. The court likewise declined to count $530,000 in personal guarantees the husband claimed to have signed, as he never produced a single one.

Signs a debt may have been manufactured to shrink the pool:

  1. It was papered or secured after separation, particularly once you lodged a caveat or began proceedings.
  2. The lender is a friend, employee or relative of your ex.
  3. Nothing has ever been repaid, and no demand has ever been made.
  4. The paper trail goes cold at your ex's company or personal account.

Are family loans counted in a property settlement?

Parents frequently bankroll their adult children, and those advances have a habit of being recast as loans once a marriage breaks down. Courts approach such claims warily.

Common Misconception: So long as your ex and the parents both insist it was a loan, the court must deduct it.

Legal Truth: The court poses two questions. Is the debt legally enforceable? And even if it is, will the lender, in reality, ever call it in? A no to either allows the court to leave the loan out of the pool.

Case Analysis: Liakos & Zervos [2011] FamCA 547

The relationship began in 1991, the couple married in 1996 and last lived together in 2006. Both the husband and his father told the court that advances made over more than 20 years left the husband owing his father $1,392,377.09. The father joined the proceedings, seeking payment out of two of the properties in priority to the wife's claim.

The wife could not dispute that the money had been advanced, and the judge accepted the debt was real. But the father had lent across two decades without receiving a cent back and without regard to whether his son could ever repay. According to the husband, they had agreed in about 1988 that repayment would wait until he got big — that is, until he was financially comfortable. The judge characterised a 2007 loan document as likely an entirely self-serving instrument aimed at holding off the wife's claims. Nor was there any evidence the wife knew of the debts.

Outcome: In fixing the net assets for division at $663,598.59, the judge made no deduction for the $1,392,377.09. The husband might never get big, and so might never have to repay his father; the father, moreover, had to shoulder some responsibility for continuing to lend to a son who was already hopelessly overextended.

"Hence, absent probative evidence of an intention to create a legal relationship of creditor and debtor in respect of those residual funds, they are not taken into account as a liability"

Documents, the purpose of the advance and the lender's true intentions decide these cases:

ComparisonLiakos & Zervos [2011]Stubbs (No 3) [2025]
Claimed amount$1,392,377.09 said to be owed to the husband's father$437,885 said to be owed to the mother's father
PaperworkOne 2007 document, likely self-serving in the court's viewFour formal loan agreements totalling $250,000; no documents for the balance
Whether repayment would be demandedNothing repaid in 20-plus years; repayable once the husband got bigThe grandfather refused to concede he would never enforce them
ResultNo deduction from the pool$150,000 counted; the legal fees loan and undocumented advances excluded

Key: Formal loan agreements carried real weight in Stubbs (No 3): they evidenced an intention to create an enforceable debt, and the lender stood behind them. In Liakos, the court accepted the debt existed yet still excluded it, because the father was never realistically going to enforce it. The legal fees loan in Stubbs (No 3) fell away for a different reason: under Chorn v Hopkins, legal fees are generally handled outside the property pool.

When your ex asserts a large family loan:

  1. Demand the loan agreement, bank records for every advance, and any record of repayments or interest.
  2. Pin down when the documents were signed. Paper created after separation counts for less.
  3. Probe the purpose. Money for your ex's legal fees is not treated like money for the household.
  4. Ask whether the lender has ever demanded repayment or gone to court.

For other debt problems in a separation, see How Do Australian Courts Divide Hidden Spouse Debt in Divorce? if the debt came to light late. Where a business or investment lost money, Is a Failed Investment Wastage in Australian Family Law? sets out when losses are shared. For the whole process, start with How Australian Courts Divide Property: The Four-Step Process (2026).

What to do when your ex's debt lands on you

A debt from the marriage is not automatically joint. In Adair & Milford, the husband could pay the tax, chose not to, and misled his wife, so the $419,000 debt stayed with him.

Negligence may split a debt rather than move it wholesale. In Vinge, years of unlodged returns left the husband carrying the penalties and half the unpaid tax, with the other half still shared.

Fraud debts generally stay with the fraudster. In Rose, the judge declined to give the husband any share of the $106,000 Centrelink debt the wife's fraud created.

Family loans must be genuine and realistically repayable. Liakos & Zervos kept a $1.39 million debt to the husband's father out of the pool, as the father was never likely to call it in.

Benefit cuts both ways. If the debt funded your lifestyle, expect to shoulder at least part of it, as the wife in James & Snipper discovered.

Do:

  • Assemble the debt's full paper trail: statements, tax assessments, loan agreements
  • Trace where the borrowed or unpaid money actually finished up
  • Highlight when the debt was incurred or secured, especially post-separation
  • Seek an order that your ex discharges the debt and indemnifies you
  • Own up to any benefit you drew from the debt

Don't:

  • Assume a debt in your ex's sole name is none of your affair
  • Take a claimed family loan at face value without documents
  • Sign a fresh loan or mortgage after separation without legal advice
  • Ignore the creditor because your ex promised to pay
  • Deny the debt while enjoying what it paid for

Need professional legal help? Check out our Property and Asset Division services.Or contact us for a case consultation. This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. For advice specific to your situation, please consult a qualified family law solicitor.

Portrait of Lingyu (Gloria) Zhao, Family Law Solicitor

About the author

Lingyu (Gloria) Zhao

Principal Lawyer

Gloria Zhao is an Australian-qualified family law solicitor with over eight years of experience guiding clients through complex property, parenting and cross-border disputes. She has acted in more than 1,800 matters and is known for strategic, results-driven advocacy.

Beyond the courtroom, Gloria is committed to legal education. She regularly creates bilingual family law content to help the community understand their rights and make confident decisions.

Get in touch

First Name *
Last Name *
Phone *
Email
Message

Related Posts

Explore related topics

26 October 202612 min read

Windfalls After Separation in Australia: Can Your Ex Claim?

Under s 79 of the Family Law Act 1975, an inheritance, payout or other windfall after separation stays in the pool, and the court then decides who gets credit.

Read More
16 September 202613 min read

Parental Deposits in Family Law Property Settlement

Under section 79 of the Family Law Act 1975, a deposit from your parents counts as your contribution alone unless they intended to benefit both of you.

Read More
9 September 202613 min read

Divorce Property Settlement in Australia: Case Examples

Under section 79 of the Family Law Act 1975, courts divide property by contributions and timing, not by title or relationship length, as these seven cases show.

Read More