Introduction
Q1: We have three kids and can't agree who they should live with. Will the court split them between us?
A: Usually not. Courts don't like separating siblings without a good reason — when a family breaks apart, the children often have only each other to hold on to. In one 2011 case the court kept three children aged 16, 13 and 12 together, even though each of them leaned towards a different arrangement. Reference: Aiken & Aiken [2011] FMCAfam 910
Q2: My eldest wants to live with their other parent, but the younger ones want to stay with me. Can the court split them up?
A: It can — but only after weighing what the split would cost every child, not just the one asking to move. In a 2009 case, a 13-year-old girl was allowed to live with her father while her two younger sisters stayed with their mother, and the timetable was arranged so the three girls still spent 10 nights out of every 14 together. Reference: Patrick & Patrick [2009] FMCAfam 326
Q3: My ex kept two of our kids after a holiday visit. Do I just have to wait for the trial?
A: No, and don't wait. The appeal court has said that a judge who lets one parent create a sibling split simply by holding on to some of the children — without weighing what that does to all of them — has made an error. In that case the father was ordered to return the children. Reference: Renald & Renald (No 2) [2017] FamCAFC 133
Does Australian family law say siblings must stay together?
No section of the Family Law Act 1975 says siblings must live in the same home — and nothing in it pushes them apart, either. When brothers and sisters end up in different households, people often reach for the phrase split custody, even though Australian law dropped the word custody long ago. Strip away the labels and the question is the one behind every parenting dispute: what is in these children's best interests? Section 60CC holds that test. Since the May 2024 amendments, section 60CC(2) has required the court to consider, among other things:
"(c) the developmental, psychological, emotional and cultural needs of the child;"
"(e) the benefit to the child of being able to have a relationship with the child's parents, and other people who are significant to the child, where it is safe to do so;"
In plain terms, the court asks what a child needs to grow up well, and what they stand to gain from staying connected to their parents and the other people who matter to them, so long as it is safe. For most children, a brother or sister is right at the top of that list, which puts the sibling relationship squarely inside paragraph (e). Before May 2024, the old section 60CC(3)(d) named it outright: the court had to weigh the likely effect on the child of separation from either parent, or from any other child the child had been living with. The cases in this article were all decided under that older wording. The question the judges ask, though, has not changed.
What the statute leaves unsaid, the case law supplies: separating siblings is a big step. Judges begin reluctant to take it, and they need a good reason to move.
The parents separated under one roof in September 2010. By the interim hearing in August 2011, the mother had moved about four hours away, and each parent wanted the three children — 16, 13 and 12 — living primarily with them. A family consultant interviewed the children on the morning of the hearing.
All three felt pressured and torn. The youngest boy wanted equal time; failing that, his mother's new town. What he kept coming back to was his worry that his siblings would be split up. The 13-year-old had the strongest pull towards her mother, though even she was anxious about losing her brothers. The eldest, 16, was in real distress. He floated going back to his father's area to finish Year 10, but said he did not want the family broken up, and worried how much he would miss the others.
Outcome: On an interim basis, all three children were to live with their mother and spend alternate weekends and part of the school holidays with their father. The heaviest weight on the scale was not which parent each child preferred. It was the one thing all three agreed on: they wanted to stay together.
However, importantly, the clear and consistent view that all three of these young people have expressed is to remain together, and particularly during this important period in their life, which has been horribly destabilised, and destabilising, through no fault of their own, and indeed, through no fault of their parents, who are entitled to make the adult choice to no longer be together.
The judge also drew on earlier Full Court decisions describing how reluctant courts are to separate siblings other than for good reason, and accepted that some cases do supply one. This just was not it. If your children are close, and each is saying in their own way that they want to stay together, that shared view is often the one a court takes most seriously.
When will a court agree to separate siblings?
When keeping the siblings together would cost one of the children more than separating them would. The most common trigger is an older child with a firm, considered wish to live with the other parent.
The parents separated in 2005. Their three daughters — 13, 12 and 10 at trial — lived mostly with their mother. The eldest had fallen out with her father over his household rules and went about nine months without seeing him. Interim orders in October 2008 restarted the visits, and somewhere in that stretch she decided she wanted to live with him.
The family report writer recommended keeping all three girls with their mother. He doubted the eldest had thought her wish through, and he took the view that siblings should not ordinarily be separated, because when parents are locked in an intractable dispute, the children are each other's protection. The eldest herself said her younger sisters should stay with their mother — they would miss her far too much.
Outcome: The eldest was ordered to live with her father and the two younger girls with their mother. The two schedules were mirrored so the sisters were together every weekend — 10 nights out of every 14 in each other's company. The judge found the eldest had thought the split through as well as a 13-year-old could, and that forcing her to stay risked an anger that would spill onto her sisters.
It is a big step to separate siblings. Siblings provide a buffer for children who are moving between two households where the adults clearly don't respect each other. It is difficult for children to move between households where there is that level of conflict.
The judge did not pretend the split was free. The two younger girls would still have each other; the eldest would carry the burden of moving between hostile households on her own. He even suggested the separation might bite harder for the younger girls than for their sister, and that the adults would have to manage it with care. That is the pattern worth noticing: a court that agrees to separate siblings does not treat their bond as disposable. It builds the timetable to keep as much of that bond intact as it can.
Can protecting a child's bond with a parent outweigh keeping siblings together?
Yes. Sometimes the sibling relationship is the factor that gives way, because keeping the children together would put a child's relationship with one parent at genuine risk.
The parents had a 13-year-old daughter (V in the judgment) and two sons aged 7 and 9. The daughter's relationship with her mother was conflicted; she lived with her father, and by the hearing both parents agreed she should stay. The boys had spent week about with each parent since separation, but that arrangement had broken down — the parents could no longer communicate, and both accepted the boys needed one main home.
The father's argument was straightforward: let the boys live mainly with him, and all three siblings would be together most of the time. The judge accepted this was a real advantage of his proposal. But he also found that the boys' unkind remarks about their mother echoed what was said in the father's home, and that living there would probably send their relationship with her the same way their sister's had gone.
Outcome: The boys were to live mainly with their mother, 10 nights a fortnight, and spend 4 nights a fortnight with their father and sister. The daughter stayed with the father. With regular contact, the judge found, the effect on the sibling relationship would be inconsequential — it was the boys' relationship with their mother that needed protecting.
The family consultant said the boys' relationship with the mother should be prioritised over being able to live most of the time with V. I agree. I accept if the boys live primarily with the mother they would still have ongoing and regular contact with their sister and, although the children would miss each other, because the amount of time the boys would be with her, the impact on the sibling relationship would be inconsequential.
The judge also noted that the three children had already spent more than a year not living together full time, and their connection had survived it. If your children already spend part of each week in separate homes and are coping, a court may be less troubled by formalising that split than you expect.
Case comparison: why were some siblings kept together and others split?
| Comparison | Aiken & Aiken [2011] | Patrick & Patrick [2009] | Holman-Lloyd & Lloyd [2010] |
|---|---|---|---|
| Children's ages | 16, 13 and 12 | 13, 12 and 10 | 13, 9 and 7 |
| What the children wanted | Mixed preferences, but all three wanted to stay together | Eldest firmly wanted to live with the father | Boys wanted a main home and felt pressured to choose |
| Main reason for the decision | Children already coping with a series of changes and needed each other | A thought-through teenage wish, and the risk her anger would affect her sisters | Protecting the boys' relationship with their mother |
| Outcome | ✅ Kept together with the mother | ❌ Eldest with the father, younger two with the mother | ❌ Daughter with the father, boys mainly with the mother |
| Time siblings spend together | Every night | 10 nights out of 14 | 4 nights a fortnight plus regular contact |
The decisive factor: every one of these courts started from the value of keeping siblings together. What separated them was whether something heavier sat on the other side of the scale. In Aiken & Aiken, nothing did, so the children stayed together. In Patrick & Patrick, it was a 13-year-old's settled wish and the harm of overriding it. In Holman-Lloyd & Lloyd, it was the risk of two young boys losing their mother. And wherever a split was ordered, the court shaped the schedule so the siblings still saw each other often.
What if the children have already split themselves between the two homes?
When older children have chosen sides by themselves, a court will not always drag them back together — least of all early in a separation. More often, it takes the pressure off, orders family therapy, and waits to see what changes.
The parents had five children: a 14-year-old, two aged 12 and 10, and four-year-old twins. Consent interim orders made in August 2021 had every child except the eldest living with the mother. In practice, it had already come apart. The 14-year-old had moved in with his father and would not see his mother. The 12- and 10-year-olds stayed with their mother and would not see their father. The twins, meanwhile, moved happily between the two homes every alternate weekend.
Both parents told the court they wanted all five children spending time together. It kept failing. The eldest would not go to the mother's home, where his four siblings lived. The middle two would not set foot in the father's unit, even when the twins were there.
Outcome: The interim orders were varied so that the eldest lived with his father and the middle two with their mother, each spending time with the other parent as they wished. Five months after the final separation, the judge declined to impose fixed arrangements on the three older children, ordered family counselling, and asked the parents to encourage all five children to celebrate two upcoming birthdays together.
The parents had already engaged a family therapist, Ms M. Building on that, the judge said:
Although Ms M’s engagement is a positive development, there is an apparent need for the parents to demonstrate to the children, through actions and words, that the relationship with their siblings and with the parent they do not currently living with, is safe and beneficial to them.
That was an interim decision, not a final one. The judge accepted the alignments might harden if nothing changed, and left no doubt about whose job it was to reconnect the children: the parents'. Where children have dug into camps, the court looks hard at what each parent is doing — in words and in actions — to keep the brothers and sisters connected.
Can one parent create a sibling split by keeping some of the children?
No. A parent who hangs on to some of the children in breach of orders cannot pass the resulting split off as the new normal. The appeal court has said the effect on all the siblings, including the ones left behind, must be weighed.
The parents had seven children and separated in 2013. Consent interim orders made in April 2016 had all seven living with their mother in Perth, with most spending long weekends and part of some school holidays with the father, who lived more than two hours away. In January 2017 the mother let three of the children visit the father for the summer holidays. He returned one and kept the other two, enrolling them in a local school and signing them up with sporting clubs.
The mother applied for a recovery order straight away. It took about six weeks to be heard, and the magistrate then refused it — unsure how strongly the two children wanted to stay, noting they had started at a new school, and pointing to the trial listed for August. The single expert had recommended against separating the siblings, and the two children had not seen their brothers and sisters for weeks.
Outcome: On appeal, Justice Thackray found the magistrate had erred, partly by failing to consider the effect of the split on all seven children. He ordered the father to return the children in his care — all except an older son, born in 2002, who could choose to stay — with a recovery order to issue if the father did not comply.
Although invited to do so by the mother's solicitor, the Magistrate failed to take into account the impact on the children of his refusal to make an order which would ensure that all the children continued to reside together. In my view, this issue was of importance given the probability that some of the children would never visit the father's home and the others would visit only occasionally.
Re-deciding the matter, Justice Thackray said he would weigh the interests of the children living with the mother just as heavily as those living with the father. He also found that the father's conduct had sent a poor message to the children at home, who were now troubled by the thought that they too might be taken and kept. The practical point is about speed: if the other parent has split your children by keeping some of them, move quickly. The longer a split is left to settle, the harder it becomes to undo.
Your situation may also turn on a child's own wishes, or on a child being kept by the other parent. These articles go further: How Much Weight Do Courts Give a Child's Views in Australia? explains how judges test what children say. Can a Child Choose Which Parent to Live With in Australia? covers the age question. Child Recovery Orders in Australia: Family Court Guide walks through what to do when a child is not returned.
How should you weigh the pros and cons of separating siblings?
Courts start from keeping siblings together, and they want a good reason to depart from it. In Aiken & Aiken, the children's shared wish to stay together counted for more than each child's individual preference for one parent.
A teenager's settled wish can justify a split, but the court checks the cost to every child. In Patrick & Patrick, the eldest moved to her father's home only after the judge asked what the split would mean for her younger sisters, and the timetable kept the girls together 10 nights a fortnight.
A child's relationship with a parent can outweigh living with a sibling. In Holman-Lloyd & Lloyd, the boys lived mainly with their mother to protect that relationship, and the court found the effect on their bond with their sister would be inconsequential.
Early in a separation, courts may leave a de facto split alone and work on repair. In Regan & Regan (No. 2), five months after separation, the judge refused to lock three older children into fixed arrangements and ordered family therapy instead.
A split created by breaching orders will not be rewarded. In Renald & Renald (No 2), the appeal court ordered children returned after a father kept them, because the effect on all seven siblings had been ignored.
| ✅ Do | ❌ Avoid |
|---|---|
| Ask what a split would mean for each child, including the ones not asking to move | Treating one child's wish as the only question |
| Build any split around regular, predictable sibling time — shared weekends, for instance | Agreeing to a split that leaves siblings rarely seeing each other |
| Show your children, in words and actions, that their relationship with their siblings is safe and valued | Letting children line up with one parent against the other |
| Apply to the court promptly if the other parent keeps some of the children | Waiting months while a split hardens into the status quo |


